Did Monogamy Arise to Protect Babies From Unrelated Males?
Medical news

 

Love songs praise the virtues of monogamy, but a new study suggests that long-term coupling began as a way to protect babies from murder by unrelated men." />
MedicineNet.com
Slideshows
Slideshow Pictures
All Slideshows
Newest Slideshows
Pet Health Slideshows
Images
Image Collection
Allergic Skin Disorders
Bacterial Skin Diseases
Bites and Infestations
Diseases of Pigment
Fungal Skin Diseases
Medical Anatomy and Illustrations
Noncancerous, Precancerous & Cancerous Tumors
Oral Health Conditions
Papules, Scales, Plaques and Eruptions
Scalp, Hair and Nails
Sexually Transmitted Diseases (STDs)
Vascular, Lymphatic and Systemic Conditions
Viral Skin Diseases
Additional Skin Conditions
Quizzes
Quizzes
Happiness - Test your emotional IQ
Superfoods - Are you eating enough?



Fat and Fats - What do you know about fat?
Skin Pictures - Can you identify these conditions?
Chronic Fatigue Syndrome - What do you know about CFS?
Conditions
Diseases & Conditions
Conditions A-Z
Procedures A-Z
Allergies
Alzheimer's
Arthritis
Asthma
Blood Pressure
Cancer
Cholesterol
Chronic Pain
Cold & Flu
Depression
Diabetes
Digestion
Eyesight
Health & Living
Healthy Kids
Hearing & Ear
Heart
HIV/AIDS
Infectious Disease
Lung Conditions
Menopause
Men's Health
Mental Health
Migraine
Neurology
Oral Health
Pregnancy
Senior Health
Sexual Health
Skin Problems
Sleep
Thyroid
Travel Health
Women's Health
Symptom Checker
Health & Living
Health & Living
Diet & Weight Management
Exercise & Fitness
Nutrition, Food & Recipes
Prevention & Wellness
Medications
Medications
Supplements and Vitamins
search
GO
October 15, 2015

Like Us
Follow Us
About Us
Newsletter
Home
Slideshow
Pictures
Slideshow Pictures
All Slideshows
Newest Slideshows
Pet Health Slideshows
Featured Slideshow

Sexual Health


Surprising Health Benefits of Sex


View Slideshow »


Image
Collection
Image Collection (categories)
Allergic Skin Disorders
Bacterial Skin Diseases
Bites and Infestations
Diseases of Pigment
Fungal Skin Diseases
Medical Anatomy and Illustrations
Noncancerous, Precancerous & Cancerous Tumors
Oral Health Conditions
Papules, Scales, Plaques and Eruptions
Scalp, Hair and Nails
Sexually Transmitted Diseases (STDs)
Vascular, Lymphatic and Systemic Conditions
Viral Skin Diseases
Additional Skin Conditions
Featured Image

Picture of Psoriasis


A reddish, scaly rash often located over the surfaces of the elbows, knees, scalp, and around or in the ears, navel, genitals or buttocks...


View Image Gallery »


Quizzes
See All Quizzes (119)
Happiness - Test your emotional IQ
Superfoods - Are you eating enough?
Fat and Fats - What do you know about fat?
Skin Pictures - Can you identify these conditions?
Chronic Fatigue Syndrome - What do you know about CFS?
Featured Quiz

Take the Sex & Love Quiz!


The brain. The body. The bedroom. What do you know?


View Quiz »


Diseases
& Conditions
Topic Centers
Conditions A-Z
Procedures A-Z
Allergies
Alzheimer's
Arthritis
Asthma
Blood Pressure
Cancer
Cholesterol
Chronic Pain
Cold & Flu
Depression
Diabetes
Digestion
Eyesight
Health & Living
Healthy Kids
Hearing & Ear
Heart
HIV/AIDS
Infectious Disease
Lung Conditions
Menopause
Men's Health
Mental Health
Migraine
Neurology
Oral Health
Pregnancy
Senior Health
Sexual Health
Skin Problems
Sleep
Thyroid
Travel Health
Women's Health
Symptom
Checker
Health
& Living
Health & Living
Diet & Weight Management
Exercise & Fitness
Nutrition, Food & Recipes
Prevention & Wellness
Featured Topic

Weight Loss


The No-Diet Approach


Learn More »


Medications
Medications
Supplements and Vitamins
MedTerms
Dictionary
Pet
Health

home > did monogamy arise to protect babies from unrelat article


Did Monogamy Arise to Protect Babies From Unrelated Males?
By Alan Mozes
HealthDay Reporter

MONDAY, July 29 (HealthDay News) -- Love songs praise the virtues of monogamy, but a new study suggests that long-term coupling began as a way to protect babies from murder by unrelated men.

According to the researchers who tracked the evolution of monogamy among primates, humans may have adopted the practice to protect their vulnerable young.

"This is the first time that the theories for the evolution of monogamy have been systematically tested, conclusively showing that [prevention of] infanticide is the driver of monogamy," study author Christopher Opie said in a statement.

Opie said his team's study, published online July 29 in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, "brings to a close the long-running debate about the origin of monogamy in primates." Opie is a post-doctoral research fellow in the department of anthropology at University College London, in England.

Opie said the findings also suggest that other benefits of monogamy -- guarding females from rival mates or allowing males to partake in childrearing, for example -- were both the result of the adoption of monogamy, not part of the cause.

As the researchers pointed out, a look around the animal kingdom shows that monogamy is a relatively rare phenomenon. Less than three percent of mammals engage in the practice.

Researchers have long sought to understand why monogamy became the norm for humans. There were three predominant theories: that a man sticks with one woman to block other male interlopers (and thereby improve his own breeding opportunities); that the relatively slow maturation of human babies requires two committed parents to split the burden; and that monogamy stopped unrelated men from killing a woman's infant (done so she could stop nursing and be free again to breed).

In the new study, Opie and his team analyzed mammalian traits across 230 species. They looked at key factors such as the development of paternal childrearing behaviors, maternal movement and living patterns, and the threat of male infanticide.

A key finding was that, among humans, only the practice of infanticide by unrelated males was present before humans took up monogamy. This suggests that long-term coupling arose as a method to stamp out the killing of infants by rogue males.

A second study, published July 29 in the journal Science, came to a slightly different conclusion -- at least for mammals as a whole. This time, a British team led by Dieter Lukas and Tim Clutton-Brock, of the University of Cambridge, wanted to discover why some mammal species pair up for life.

Using a complex genetic analysis of more than 2,500 species, they found that the key may lie in whether females of the species live in close proximity to each other or are spread far apart. If the latter is the case, males simply cannot guard multiple females from other males, so monogamy becomes the norm.

The team said the findings may not apply to humans, however, because human evolution involved "cultural adaptations" that set the species apart from other mammals, Clutton-Brock said in a university news release.

And not all experts agreed with Opie's findings. Catherine Salmon is an associate professor of psychology and chairwoman of the department of psychology at the University of Redlands in Redlands, Calif. She was doubtful that the adoption of monogamy by humans could be tied to any one factor.

"I don't think child protection as one factor [in the mix] is at all surprising," she said. "Monogamy would offer a huge advantage in terms of protection from predators -- human or otherwise. But the idea that monogamy is mainly infanticide-driven is surprising, and I'm not entirely convinced."

"For one, although our infants are very vulnerable, I don't see the adaptive advantage for unrelated human males to commit infanticide," Salmon said. "In lions, it makes sense because when the unrelated male kills another's offspring, that brings the lioness into heat again, making her available to him. And if you're a lion, that's really the way to get in there and make your babies. But no one has ever demonstrated that humans work like that."

"The other thing," she added, "is that if human males were highly infanticidal, you would expect there would still be some remnant of that drive in human males today. But while human males are perhaps not as captivated by babies as females, they're not particularly infanticidal."

Salmon said, however, that men do seem to have "remnant" drives that predispose them to promiscuity.

"Men can ... be most successful reproductively by having sex with as many women as possible," she said. "Of course, many guys entertain sexual thoughts that they don't act upon. But many do, as we can see with the case of Anthony Weiner in New York. That's a remnant that is plain to see."